Narrative :: Jonah: Introduction Notes on ch: 1 2 3 4
Study Notes on Jonah (including Hebrew narrative) by Tim Bulkeley
The opening words of the book, by their similarity to other prophetic books, present Jonah as a prophet. His name confirms this for the attentive reader familiar with the story of Israel as told in 1 Kings. Jonah is not merely a prophet but a famous one.
This dissonance instantly makes his character problematic. The flashback of 1:5 suggests further dissonant behaviour, "while" the crew are so frightened by the storm that they crying to their "gods" and throwing the cargo overboard, Jonah is down in the hold, where he has "lain down" and is "fast asleep"!
Jonah continues to act in contrary ways, when the lot has picked him out as the cause of the problem, he proudly boasts of his religious and ethnic identity (1:9). While the sailors ask God's pardon before throwing Jonah to the waves, and continue with sacrifices after, Jonah safe in the belly of the fish shows no sign of repentance! The great success of his brief sermon in Nineveh produces either no reaction from Jonah, or displeasure and anger (4:1).
However, from this point on the character and his words begin to fit together in a more coherent way. He tells us that God's decision to spare Nineveh, following their repentance, is what he feared at the start, thus explaining the motive of his flight towards Tarshish (4:2a). Adonai's tendency to pardon and Jonah's - presumed - desire to see wicked Nineveh punished, explains his flight and resignation.
God may stubbornly seek to convert and to pardon wicked Nineveh (1:2) but his prophet is also stubborn. Following the divine repentance (3:10) and Adonai's implied refusal to allow the unwilling prophet death (4:3-4), Jonah still waits "to see what would become of the city" (4:5).
Jonah's stubbornness is reinforced when God asks him a second time if he is "right" to be angry, for Jonah denies what God implies and proclaims himself "angry enough to die" (4:9).
© Tim Bulkeley, 2003